This Pristine ’90s Off-Road Classic Is Poised to Be a Toyota Game-Changer

Hide your wallets, 4Runner fans, because this might be one of the cleanest third gens to hit the market in quite some time.

Close-up of a white Toyota 4Runner rear with a black rear windshield wiper and chrome Toyota emblem.

Add Gear Patrol as a Preferred Source on Google

By Gray Van Dyke

Published May 5, 2026

·

Growing up, one of my favorite family cars was our 1997 4Runner. As a kid riding around in the back, I wasn’t really aware of the Toyota’s many merits, but its versatility and dependability made it a constant presence, an honorary member of our household.

When a move overseas eventually forced the sale of the beloved SUV, my dad was well aware of what he was giving up down the road. Even back then, the third gen had the makings of a future classic, highly regarded despite the arrival of its technically superior successor.

White Toyota 4Runner SUV with chrome bumper and roof rack parked on pavement with autumn trees in background. — This third-generation 4Runner is the subject of some serious attention, according to Mecum.

We often kick ourselves for not making more of an effort to hold onto that Toyota 4Runner (perhaps a little more selfishly in my case). Now, with the way the market looks to be headed, that’s hindsight that stings more than ever.

The star of the show

Just take a look at Mecum’s 2026 Indianapolis lineup, for instance. Nestled amidst the usual mix of blue-chip hypercars and classic Americana, you’ll find a humble 1996 4Runner SR5.

Beige cloth car interior with front seats, black steering wheel, and dashboard with air vents and controls. — That cloth interior is beige in the best (read: most nostalgic) kind of way.

Granted, a ‘90s Toyota is far from the most commonplace vehicle to go under the company’s hammer, so auction presence alone isn’t something that makes headlines. Moreover, it’s not your garden-variety Facebook Marketplace 4Runner project, as the vehicle in question shows a mere 6,951 miles on the clock.

Rather, it’s the potential of this sale (and its pre-auction speculation) to shape the market going forward. As reported by The Drive, Mecum’s senior communications manager stated in an email that this particular Toyota has received the highest clicks of any lot in the auction.

Now, that’s not without some good reason. Beyond boasting a low odometer count, this third-gen looks to be shockingly pristine and comes equipped with all of its factory fittings.

Front view of a silver Toyota SUV with chrome bumper and black grille parked outdoors. — Though it’s undeniably ’90s, the third generation has a classic appeal that never really went out of style. Even still, feel old yet?

Still, that kind of interest in a Toyota outfitted with Oak Sport Cloth upholstery and a four-speed automatic is telling. Even as eye candy for window shoppers, it’s not something that should be vying for interest with showstoppers like Shelby Mustangs or rare Corvettes.

Towards that end, while it makes for a comparatively grounded auction prospect relative to more exotic lots, it’s not cheap. Mecum pre-auction estimates project a final sale of anywhere from $35,000 to $45,000, so it’s poised to bring home big money.

Car dashboard showing speedometer, tachometer, and fuel gauge behind a steering wheel. — That kind of mileage is a rare sight on any old Toyota, and especially 4Runners.

Supported by past sales

But could it climb higher still, and is this a sign that the third-generation 4Runner has entered its classic era? If past results are anything to go by, collectors are certainly beginning to come around.

After all, Mecum’s estimates seem much less ambitious when you consider some of the sales on online platforms like Bring a Trailer. This past April, one N180 4Runner hit $46,555 in bidding. While it was a newer 2000 model, it also showed more mileage with nearly 20,000 turns on the odometer.

Silver Toyota SUV with tinted windows parked on a concrete surface with trees in the background. — Factory originality is something else that you don’t often see with older enthusiast-capable vehicles like the 4Runner.

It’s not an exceptional result or a recent trend, either. If you look through Bring a Trailer’s other 4Runner sales, you’ll find that more than a few examples have crossed the $35,000 mark, and one of the highest results came back in May 2020 from a 1996 SR5.

Whether the lack of leather seats or a manual transmission will deter buyers from ponying up with this auction, only time will tell.

If for no other reason other than the hype it’s generating, though, this 4Runner has the potential to bring some big changes to the current third-generation market.

Silver Toyota 4Runner SR5 SUV parked on pavement with autumn trees in the background. — Regardless of whether the mileage and condition can carry this Toyota to a new 4Runner auction high, it’s a shockingly pristine example.

Yours to own (or admire)

Should you be looking to catch this 1996 Toyota 4Runner as part of Mecum’s 2026 Indianapolis auction, it’ll cross the block on May 14th. I know my own nostalgia will have me watching for the result.

About the Author: Gray is an associate editor at Gear Patrol, covering cars, motorcycles and anything else with wheels. When he’s not chasing the latest industry news, he’s probably wrenching on one of many projects. For better or worse, he believes classics make perfectly practical daily drivers.

Want to stay up to date on the latest product news and releases? Add Gear Patrol as a preferred source to ensure our independent journalism makes it to the top of your Google search results.