Every product is carefully selected by our editors. If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission.

This Is the Best Hybrid Smartwatch I’ve Ever Worn

Reviewing the first hybrid analog smartwatch to feature heart rate monitoring.

At a recent physical, a feeling of shame washed over me as I answered my doctor’s litany of standard questions. Profession? Writer who works from home. Familial history of heart disease or diabetes? Yes, on both sides. What’s your diet like? Well, I had kale the other night, but there was pasta, bacon and eggs, too. Do you exercise? Not as often as I should.

“Hmm,” he said, then made a judgemental ticking sound with his mouth. “I’d get out and walk more if I were you.” I immediately glanced at the watch I was wearing, feeling disgraced. I didn’t need a doctor to tell me this. I had recently started wearing a Nokia Steel HR — just one of many hybrid analog smartwatches to recently hit the market — that had been tracking my woefully inadequate level of activity.

Of course, I didn’t really need a watch to tell me this either. When I had made the switch to telecommuting, I was grateful I no longer had to take New York’s hellish subway every day, but I also missed out on two and a half miles my daily commute once required. I don’t need to walk to buy a lunch, which is great for the wallet but bad for the ticker. I became complacent sitting behind a computer, which made it all too easy to brush off a certain degree of inactivity. The day after my physical, I finally went out and did what I hadn’t done in months: I went for a run, even though running is awful.

While I have used a couple hybrid smartwatches during exercise, the Steel HR blows them out of the water in terms of actual usefulness while working out. The key is that “HR.” As of writing, the Nokia Steel HR (formerly the Withings Steel HR, before Nokia’s acquisition of the French tech brand) is the only analog hybrid on the market that can measure your heart rate, which it does through an optical sensor on the back of the case. That means that when you’re working out, you get a constant reading of your heart rate. This is great compared to other hybrids, as you can adjust your pace to make sure your heart rate is in the sweet spot. Also unlike other hybrids, the Steel HR displays a running time for your workout.

One of its critical features is a screen in the guise of a sub-dial at 12 o’clock. Other manufacturers have shied away from screens in favor of old-school gauges that monitor the progress of your set goal, perhaps in some attempt to preserve the sanctity of the purely-analog watch, but a screen is just so much better at giving you nuanced information. I do understand the desire to keep things classically styled, but if you have the black-dial variant there’s not much to indicate the Steel HR is anything other than a regular quartz watch — that screen sub-dial shuts down and blends in with the rest of the dial unless you press in the crown. When you do, you get basic info like the date, your current heart rate, your daily steps, calories burned and the distance traveled.

The Steel HR also bests other hybrids in user-friendliness. Syncing to your smartphone is quick and automatic (you don’t need to press in the crow). The accompanying HelathMate app is also intuitive. It gives a clear readout of activity data, sleep data and allows you to set alarms, which are far better than a typical smartphone alarm. The watch vibrates at the set time to jostle you awake which is not only a more pleasant way to wake up, it also only wakes you up. Your significant other will appreciate this.

This is to say nothing of the watch’s construction. The Steel HR’s case is light, thin and, while not polished to the point where it could pass as a dress watch, it’s trim enough not to hint at its connected leanings and to work in most (if not all) casual situations. It looks just as good as any other hybrid out there — the minimalist Bauhaus aesthetic works well. The silicon strap (specced on my review unit) affixed to the Steel HR is made from a particularly soft, supple rubber. So while it isn’t exactly luxurious, it makes it incredibly comfortable to wear in bed.

There are still shortcomings. Those looking for hardcore fitness trackers probably won’t be impressed. The watch relies on its step counter to register distances, so it isn’t as accurate as a GPS-enabled fitness tracker. Further, its fitness tracking abilities are mostly limited to running and swimming. There aren’t many other smart features beyond fitness tracking either — you can get phone and text notifications, but that’s pretty much it. Users may also be dismayed by the 25-day battery life (potentially shorter depending on how often you use the heart rate monitor), though recharging the lithium-ion battery only takes about an hour.

But while it still may be inherently compromised when compared to full-on smartwatches, as far as hybrids go, this feels like the most realized example yet. No, it may not work for hardcore fitness buffs or, conversely, techies looking for the latest and greatest in features. But for a writer who could stand to get out a little more? It proved to be almost perfect.

Buy Now: $180

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
More From Watches