Buffalo Trace Revisits Some Classic Whiskeys with Its Latest Release

This collection resurrects long-forgotten brands from the Prohibition era.

Top portion of a whiskey bottle with a cork stopper and a label reading "Henry Watterson" on a gradient brown background.Buffalo Trace

If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission. Learn more

Prohibition was inarguably a dark period for the American distilling industry. Aside from accelerating the rise of organized crime in the 1920s, it also led to the shuttering of, by some estimates, over 2,000 distilleries (including one owned by this writer’s great-grandfather) — most of which did not resume operations after the repeal in 1933.

One thing, however, that Prohibition did give us was the mythology of the era, from speakeasies to bootleggers to the revival of cocktail culture. Buffalo Trace has certainly hopped on board with that romanticism. And since it was there (under George T. Stagg Distillery as one of just six distilleries licensed to sell medicinal alcohol), the Kentucky icon is better equipped to tell the story than most.

Five bottles of Buffalo Trace Distillery bourbon whiskey lined up, each with distinct labels including Walter B. Duffy, John G. Carlisle, and Kentucky River.
Buffalo Trace debuts its 3rd-annual Prohibition Collection, where it revives archival labels that no longer exist.
Buffalo Trace

For the third-annual Prohibition Collection, it revives five archival whiskey brands that existed during Prohibition in one form or another. And this year’s selection is the most ambitious yet.

Bottle of Henry Watterson Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey with a yellow label and cork stopper.
Named after an anti-Prohibition journalist and congressman, Henry Watterson was a former medicinal alcohol label from the ’20s.
Buffalo Trace

Need more proof?

Leading the pack is Henry Watterson, a straight rye whiskey bottled at a jaw-dropping 140.6 proof (70.3% ABV), making it one of the few hazmat-proof ryes on the market. The palate hits with “rye spice, citrus peel and fresh green herbs” that you’ll undoubtedly experience with amplified intensity here.

Bottle and box of Henry Watterson Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey with a filled whiskey glass on a wooden surface.
At 140.6 proof, this is one of the hottest straight rye whiskeys on the market.
Buffalo Trace

The label itself was a real medicinal whiskey sold and distributed by George T. Stagg in the 1920s. Back then, it was common for expressions to be named after famous figures of the time. Watterson was an anti-Prohibition journalist and former congressman for Kentucky.

Bottle of Kentucky River whiskey with amber liquid and white label featuring red and black text.
Kentucky River is a straight whiskey blend.
Buffalo Trace

A couple of blends

Next up is Kentucky River, a traditional 100-proof blend of straight whiskeys. It honors a medicinal alcohol brand that was named, according to Buffalo Trace, “under Albert Blanton’s leadership to honor the river’s vital role in transporting goods, people and materials.” The modern expression delivers a palate of “baked apple and gentle oak.”

Bottle of Walter B. Duffy Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey with yellow and red label.
Walter B. Duffy combines 10- and 14-year-old bourbons at 100 proof.
Buffalo Trace

A second blend is part of the collection, but is much more premium in nature. Walter B. Duffy combines 10- and 14-year bourbon barrels as a 107-proof expression. Tasting notes include “graham cracker, toasted corn and oak, layered with dried fig, raisin and date” on the palate. Duffy himself took over as owner of the distillery (then called O.F.C. Distillery) following George T. Stagg’s death in 1893. During Prohibition, he then appointed Blanton as president of the company in 1921.

Bottle of John G. Carlisle Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey with yellow and white label.
Named after a crucial figure to the Bottled-in-Bond Act of 1897, John G. Carlisle is an aptly bonded bourbon.
Buffalo Trace

Two more of note

Based on yet another medicinal label, the John G. Carlisle expression is a bottled-in-bond bourbon that’s pours at 100 proof and is at least four years old. Carlisle was an important figure at the turn of the 20th century. An ally of Colonel E.H. Taylor, Jr., the founder of O.F.C. Distillery, Carlisle helped create the Bottled-in-Bond Act of 1897, which was the first federal regulation specifically for whiskey. This modern whiskey features “bright orchard fruit and subtle tropical notes balanced by vanilla, oak and warm baking spices” on the palate.

Rectangular bottle of Cove Spring Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey with amber liquid and a label featuring a forest scene.
The lone wheated bourbon of the bunch is Cove Spring, named after the natural spring that supplied water to the distillery during its early years.
Buffalo Trace

Lastly, Cove Spring is the sole wheated bourbon of the bunch. Bottled at 120.2 proof, the whiskey is, yet again, named after a medicinal label from Prohibition that was dug out of the archives. It was originally named after a natural spring-turned-reservoir that supplied water to the distillery during its early years. This expression offers a palate “layered with sweet corn and spice, before giving way to a long, balanced finish marked by red fruit, toasted oak and lingering warmth.”

Six bottles of Buffalo Trace Distillery whiskey with matching boxes, including Walter B. Duffy, John C. Carlisle, Kentucky River, and Henry Watterson.
The five expressions are sold as a set, priced at $1,000.
Buffalo Trace

Availability and pricing

Only a limited number of the Prohibition Collection #3 will be available to purchase when it rolls out in the coming weeks. All five expressions will arrive in 375mL bottles, combined together in a single wooden box with archival imagery. The set has a suggested retail price of $1,000.

Five bottles of Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey with colorful labels and wooden corks lined up on a wooden surface.Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace Prohibition Collection #3

Want to stay up to date on the latest product news and releases? Add Gear Patrol as a preferred source to ensure our independent journalism makes it to the top of your Google search results.

add as a preferred source on google
, , , ,