Every product is carefully selected by our editors. If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission.

This Is the Best Cup of Coffee in America — Here’s How to Make It

From Dylan Siemans, winner of the Brewers Cup at the 2017 U.S.

Chase Pellerin

In the era of push-button, single-cup brewers, manual coffee methods serve as a celebration of process and precision. A quality cup of coffee is marked by a balance of ingredients, with different variables — coffee roast, coarseness of grounds, water quality, temperature, time — working in tandem to elevate the final cup. Nowhere is this more apparent than at the U.S. Coffee Championships, a competition that draws the country’s best and most obsessive baristas, brewers and roasters, challenging them to yield their most balanced espressos, pour-overs and roasts.

At the 2017 U.S. Coffee Championships, held in Seattle earlier this year, Dylan Siemans of Onyx Coffee Lab in Northwest Arkansas was crowned winner of the Brewers Cup, graded according to aroma, flavor, aftertaste, acidity, body and balance. Siemans’ winning pour-over was made using a lactic acid–processed Colombian bean and mineral-balanced water — but it was on temperature, not recipe, that Siemans focused most.

“Temperature correlates to extraction rate, which correlates to flavor perception, so by manipulating bed temperature, you can extend or curtail certain flavors,” Siemans explained, calling temperature a “really effective [variable] in dialing in a coffee’s flavor.” While temperature goes a long way in steering the flavor of a brew, it’s the core components — water and grounds — that lay the foundation.

“All coffees want to be brewed in a particular way, and you’ll make some beautiful coffees just by experimenting.”

To ensure that their fundamental ingredients were of the highest caliber, all competitors at the U.S. Coffee Championship brewed with Third Wave Water, which re-mineralizes purified water to produce brighter, more consistent flavors. The next consideration is the grounds themselves: “Uniform grind size leads to a uniform extraction rate,” Siemans says. “Use a burr grinder. Whether a hand grinder or a machine, burr blades make all the difference.” Coffee-to-water ratio most directly impacts the strength of a brew, but coarseness of coffee grounds plays into flavor concentration, as well; the finer the grind, the more slowly water will seep through the grounds and the more bitter the resultant coffee will be.

There’s a science to it all — hyper-precise formulas enough to make the heads of even the most finicky coffee drinkers spin. But, Siemans said, it’s more about experimentation than pretension. “All coffees want to be brewed in a particular way, and you’ll make some beautiful coffees just by experimenting. That’s how I discovered the formula for this competition.” In other words, toy with the coarseness of a grind, with water temperature, with quantities. See how flavors change with each variable adjusted. The worst that comes of it is a bad cup of coffee — which, in the end, really isn’t so bad.

The Gear

Championship Pour-Over Equipment


Beans: Onyx Coffee Lab Colombia La Palma Estate Series SL-28 Learn More
Grinder: Mahlkonig EK43 $2,700
Coffee Dripper: Kalita #185 Wave Ceramic Dripper $25
Filter: Kalita #185 Wave Paper Filter $8
Water Supplement: Third Wave Water $15
Kettle: Kalita Wave Kettle $40
Temperature Probe: Lavatools Javelin PRO Instant Read Thermometer $50

Brew It

A Step-by-Step Guide to Making Award-Winning Coffee


1. Grind 25 grams of coffee beans using the Malkhonig EK-43 on setting #6 (medium-fine).

2. Add one packet of Third Wave Water to one gallon of distilled water.

3. Place the Cremaware cup on a scale and calibrate it so that it registers 0 grams with the mug on it.

4. Preheat the ceramic dripper by running 200°F water through it.

5. Using the Kalita Wave Kettle, heat water to 202°.

6. Start a timer. You’ll make five separate pours over the course of two and a half minutes, during which the temperature of the water in the kettle will drop from 202° to 196°:

  • First pour at 0:00: Add 70 grams of water and stir the blooming coffee three times. Coffee bed, or grounds in the filter, temperature: 176°.
  • Pour 2 at 0:40: Add 110 grams of water. Coffee bed temperature: 186°.
  • Pour 3 at 1:00: Add 70 grams of water. Coffee bed temperature: 188°.
  • Pour 4 at 1:15: Another 70 grams of water. Coffee bed temperature: 188°.
  • Pour 5 at 1:45: Final 40 grams of water for a total of 370 grams. Coffee bed temperature: 186° and dropping.

    7. Let the water drain for 45 seconds, until the timer hits 2:30.

    8. Enjoy while hot.

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
    More From Coffee