The Longest-Running Bourbon Distillery Just Brought Back Its Rarest Whiskey

Old Forester’s historic single barrel release is now more accessible than ever.

Top portion of a brown liquor bottle with a black cap and a blue seal labeled "OLD FORESTER" against a gradient teal background.Old Forester

If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission. Learn more

In the lineage of bourbon whiskey, there are many storied brands and distilleries. But few can claim to have uninterrupted sales, even through Prohibition. 

Hailing from Louisville, Kentucky, Old Forester has the longest unbroken operation of any bourbon brand in the country: since 1870. During Prohibition, its parent company Brown-Forman was one of the only companies permitted to sell whiskey for medicinal purposes. 

This week, Old Forester is announcing the latest entry in one of its most prestigious series ever, and you might actually be able to nab a bottle (or two).

Bottle of Old Forester President's Choice Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky on a reflective surface with blurred bar background.
President’s Choice is a modern iteration of Old Forester’s private single-barrel releases dating as far back as the 1940s.
Old Forester

The original single-barrel bourbon

Long before Blanton’s popularized the idea of single-barrel bottlings in the ‘80s, Old Forester had its own version. Starting in 1946, the company’s president George Garvin Brown II would hand-pick exquisite barrels to bottle as gifts for employees and VIPs.

It wasn’t until the late ‘60s that the brand decided to release these commercially, with a catch. In order to purchase a bottle of the “President’s Choice,” you had to purchase the entire barrel outright. It wasn’t too dissimilar to today’s barrel select programs.

The original commercial run ended in the ‘70s following the death of Brown II. However, in 2018, Old Forester revived the President’s Choice series, this time as an annual limited-edition release. But for the past two editions, we’ve seen a couple of things change.

Two bottles of Old Forester whiskey and a glass with whiskey on wooden round stands against a dark teal background.
For just the second time ever, the series is getting a rye expression as well.
Old Forester

Rye not?

The 2025 release of President’s Choice saw two welcomed evolutions in the series. For starters, on top of the bourbon expression unveiled each year, we started getting a rye whiskey as well. Rye has been significantly more popular among consumers in recent years and Old Forester’s standard offerings have always been excellent.

Bottle of Old Forester President's Choice Kentucky Straight Rye Whisky on a white marble surface with a dark green paneled background.
This year, the bottle allocation isn’t just limited to Kentucky; most states can have the bottles shipped to them upon release.
Old Forester

The other big change is the shift in age range of the barrels selected. Before 2025, the age statement on President’s Choice bottles varied from 7 to 12 years. However, that number has gone down to 7 to 9 years. Regardless of how the lower age affects the whiskey’s taste, it’s also helped contribute to a wider allocation.

Previously, President’s Choice was highly limited to the distillery’s on-site shop and select Kentucky retailers. Now, you can get it nationwide. But it still won’t be easy to find.

Close-up of a dark amber whiskey bottle labeled "The President's Choice" Kentucky Straight Rye Whisky with a green and gold bordered cream label.
The age, barrel number and alcohol by volume are hand-written on each label.
Old Forester

Each bottle’s label has its specific age (in months), barrel number and ABV (ranging from 55% to 62.5%) marked by hand. Tasting notes will also vary from whiskey to whiskey, depending on which barrel it comes from.

Availability and pricing

Old Forester will be debuting its President’s Choice 2026 whiskeys on June 13 at 10 a.m. ET from its distillery shop and online store. The suggested retail price is $225.

Want to stay up to date on the latest product news and releases? Add Gear Patrol as a preferred source to ensure our independent journalism makes it to the top of your Google search results.

add as a preferred source on google
, , ,